Owing to the screen size of your device, you may obtain a better viewing experience by rotating your device a quarter-turn (to get the so-called "panorama" screen view).
Click here for the site directory.
  Please consider linking to this site! Click here to email us.

Colored Plastic Mulches for Vegetable Gardening

  Sponsored link/s:

  Sponsored link/s:

General Principles

In northern climes, heat-loving vegetables are obviously something of a challenge to grow, or at least to grow well. Any and every trick available to the gardener is wanted. Mulches are one such tool, and an important one.

A plastic mulch can do some or all of several things. First, it greatly reduces evaporation from the soil, so that water needs are easier to manage (and most heat-loving plants are also thirsty plants). Second--and the commonest reason for its use--it can hold the temperature of the soil significantly above what it would otherwise be. Third, it can virtually eliminate weeds, and thus weeding. Fourth, if its color is matched to the vegetables growing in it, it can materially enhance productivity.

Note carefully all the uses of can in those statements. Except for reducing evaporation, none of the possible benefits are automatic, but depend very much on the exact type of mulch selected and on its use by the gardener.

Soil temperature

Plastic mulches have long been used by gardeners, home and commercial, in the belief that they will materially raise soil temperatures. They can do so, but application is crucial: the underside of the mulch must be in direct, firm contact with the soil over the entire mulched area. Commercial growers can manage that by use of large, expensive, highly specialized machines; home growers have to rely on a deal of care that too few use. Just spreading a sheet of plastic polyethelene over a strip of soil will most likely not provide any temperature benefit, because the plastic will be in, at best, irregular spot contact with the actual soil surface. To make plastic mulches effective as soil-temperature raisers, we need to make sure that the soil to be covered is as smoothed-out as we can make it, preferably with a slight curvature to it (highest in the middle, sloping slightly down to the edges) and that we then apply the mulch as tightly and firmly as possible, and somehow seal it well at the strip edges. (Typically, one buries the edges slightly into the soil.)

Plain black plastic was long the material of choice for mulching, and still predominates in cool climates (in hot areas, white plastic is often used to reduce otherwise-excessive soil temperatures). An alternative is clear plastic: it provides substantially greater soil heating than black, but at a high price--rampant weed growth under it. The physics of the thing is this:

Black-plastic mulch, when struck by sunlight, absorbs most of the energy in that light at all the wavelengths of significance--ultra-violet, visible, and infrared--then re-emits that energy as long-wavelength ("thermal") radiation. Because both faces of the sheet--the groundward and the skyward--radiate, a lot of the absorbed energy ends up lost, pumped back into the air. But if the mulch is in thorough contact with the soil under it, a much larger fraction of the re-radiated energy will be carried into the soil, which has a far higher thermal conductivity than air. Soil temperatures under well-fitted black plastic mulch during the daytime are generally 5° F. higher at a 2-inch depth, and 3° F. higher at a 4-inch depth, than those of bare soil.

Clear plastic, on the other hand, obviously absorbs very little solar energy itself, but passes the great majority through to the soil under it. Owing to the soil warmth and the inpenetrability of the mulch to moisture, the underside of a clear-plastic mulch is normally covered with condensed water. That water is transparent to the incoming shortwave radiation from the sunlight, but opaque to the outgoing longwave infrared re-radiation from the soil. In English, that means that the combination of mulch-plus-moisture-film lets energy go down from sun to soil, but blocks energy from going up from soil to air--just like a greenhouse wall. Daytime soil temperatures under clear plastic mulch are generally 8° to 14° F. higher at a 2-inch depth, and 6° to 9°. F. higher at a 4-inch depth, than those of bare soil.

Wouldn't it be nice if one could somehow "average out" the two mulch types? Nowadays, that very thing is possible, with the advent of so-called "Infra-Red Transmitting" (IRT) plastic mulches. These wonderful toys absorb photosynthetically active radiation (PAR) but transmit solar-infrared radiation (IR); since it's the PAR that energizes plants--the weeds we don't want under the mulch--they're starved of light energy, while the heat-bearing IR goes on to warm the soil. Weeds are stopped, yet we get a heating effect notably greater than that from plain black mulch (intermediate between black and clear mulch in soil-temperature effects).

(Note: "IRT" is still commonly used as a generic name for this type of mulch, but it is now formally a trade name, belonging to a particular manufacturer of it. There are apparently "grades" of it--depending on transmissivity--such as IRT 76 or IRT 100.)

Color Effects

In recent years, it has been shown that selecting a plastic mulch of the right color--with "right" depending on the plants being grown--can materially improve growth and yield. There is nothing mystic or new-age about that: it's simple physics and biology. Plants grow by converting sunlight to chemical energy by photosynthesis, a process depending on the marvellous properties of chlorophyll. But the physics and chemistry of that process make it quite sensitive to the exact wavelength of the light--plants can't use all light with equal facility, which is why we have to pay through the nose for fancy "grow-light" fluorescent tubes for seedling lights. The colored mulches reflect particular wavelengths of sunlight back up onto the leaves of the plants above them.

Once the basic principle was realized, expermienters tried different colored mulches and discovered that different vegetables thrive on different light wavelengths, and hence on different-colored mulches.

(When reading anything about colored plastic mulches, it is very important to look at the date of the article: this is a very fast-developing field, and reports from the middle or even late 1990s may, or may not, be well out of date.)

Research continues, most notably at the Pennsylvania State University Plasticulture Center; most of the information to be found today is simply their work parroted back by some other source.

In a summary they set forth in 2000, they noted that though many vegetables can be grown successfully using plastic mulches, cucumbers, eggplant, muskmelons, okra peppers, squash, tomatoes, and watermelons showed the most significant responses. By vegetable, their notes, here quoted nearly verbatim, are:

Why onions were reported on even though not listed as showing "significant responses" is unclear, as is the omission of okra from the summary; watermelon, one supposes, can be assumed to respond much like muskmelons ("cantelopes"). Moreover, the potato comments, even though cleaned up a bit above, are still more than puzzling as to optimum mulch color. The metallized-silver mulch has the effect of lowering soil temperatures, which is said to increase potato tuber production, hence the concern about emergence. Our guess is that the home gardener wanting to experiment with metallized-silver plastic mulch for potatoes would be best to wait for emergence before laying down the mulch, something impossible for commercial operators but possible, by careful hand labor, for the home gardener.

In their literature, the researchers also reported that yellow plastic seems to be quite attractive to unwanted insects, and it is sometimes used in commercial practice as a "catch" for that purpose (that is, a few rows are set out here and there on yellow, and pest control vigorously applied to those particular rows).

If we turn their summary "upside-down"--that is, list by mulch color instead of vegetable--what we get is this:

(Another source of plastic-mulch information is the American Society for Plasticulture.)

Other Materials

As a possible alternative to plastic, colored-paper mulches are being developed. Their benefits are chiefly to commercial growers, who would be relieved of the task of taking up plastic after the growing season, as the paper sorts are intended to biodegrade. Such materials are still under development.

Practical Usage

Summing Up

First, get this clear: folklore and many reports notwithstanding, black plastic mulches in the home garden will, in general, not provide much soil-warming effect; it takes heroic efforts to get plastic mulch tautly bonded to the underlying soil well enough to make the kinds of differences potentially available. Their real use is conserving soil moisture and defeating weeds. For material soil warming (that does not rely on letter-perfect installation), it's clear or IRT mulches: clear ones if weed competition is not a big factor, else IRTs.

One scheme some have used is a season of black plastic, followed by a season of clear--the black having eliminated most of the weeds, and thus their seed, in its time. Also, some plants, given warm soil, will grow so quickly that their leaf canopy will shadow out most weed competition (that is especially in a deep-dug bed, where plants can be spaced close enough that their leaf growth provides essentially a near-solid canopy, or "living mulch"). Whether a season of IRT could be alternated with a season of clear is not certain, but it should work, and would not require a season of only minimal soil warming.

By the way, do not try the cheapskate's alternative to colored mulches, which is black plastic painted by the user. The "color" requirements include a lot outside the range of human vision, and even experienced colored-mulch experts trying the trick have found that they could not come even close to meeting the standards of integrally colored plastic (their results were later evaluated with measuring equipment).

There is some question--the literature is unclear and often contradictory--on whether colored plastic mulches provide any soil-warming benefits beyond what simple black does. Other than the IRT ones, whose color is more or less incidental to their function, there doesn't seem to be any reason why they should. Some sources report tomatoes (the favorite subject crop) growing better on red, while others find growth just as good on IRT mulches. Yet other sources claim substantial soil warming from colored mulches.

Our Thoughts

One thing that seems to emerge from the discussions is that the value of colored mulches at least, if not all mulches, decreases as conditions more nearly approximate ideal for the plant in question; in other words, they help make up for deficiencies, and probably wouldn't have much effect in a perfect garden.

In our climate, the warm-weather crops can be very roughly divided into two classes: the ordinary and the difficult. The "ordinary" would be those crops--such as tomatoes, peppers, squash, or potatoes--for which reasonable care in selecting sowing and transplanting dates, plus some "insurance" in the form of row cover or heat traps (Walls o'Water or water-filled clear-plastic bottles among the seedlings) should be more than enough in any but the strangest of seasons to assure a good crop. The difficult would be those crops which we are really stretching to grow here--eggplants, melons, cucumbers, and the like.

With the "ordinary" warm-weather crops (mostly the Solanaceae), we don't urgently need the soil-warming effect--though any extra helps--and so we'll go for the color-reflection benefits; for the tricky ones, we'll opt for the IRT type and its soil-warming effects. After a season or two, we'll see what there is to see and decide whether to change course.

Use Notes

  1. Use drip irrigation: plants grown with mulch are plants with good-sized inter-plant separations, making drip irrigation a natural complement to the mulching. Think about whether you want the drip system under or above the mulch, and install accordingly.

  2. Lay the mulch as early as you can, to get the most soil-warming benefit by planting or transplanting time; you can even lay it in the autumn, as soon as the beds in question are free and have been treated (that is, re-spaded if necessary, and composted or fertilized as appropriate) as the new crop may require, though consider whether the material can last through a winter then spring then summer without deteriorating (experience helps here).

  3. Make sure the soil is quite moist before laying the mulch; water well as necessary to achieve that state.

  4. Just before laying the mulch, soften and smooth the soil as best possible, possibly giving it a very slight mounding--you want the plastic to bond as closely as possible to the soil surface (plus you absolutely, positively do not want rain puddling on the mulch).

  5. Stretch the plastic as taut as reasonably possible (but do remember that you're going to have to cut holes in it for the plants, so don't go crazy); and be sure to seal the edges well.

  6. When planting seeds or seedlings, make the hole cuts as small as possible (X-cuts usually work best.

  7. Be sure to complement plastic mulches with row-cover material of some sort.

Also keep in mind that plastic mulches are not a true commodity--there are substantial differences in quality between brands. The most obvious defect is a bleaching or changing of color during the season, which will greatly reduce the benefits of wavelength-selective mulches. Red-plastic mulches made by Sunoco and Polyon have been reported to be of good quality, but the home gardener may not have the option of selecting a brand name.

It is no longer straightforward to keep a list here of actual manufacturers, but when you see the stuff offered at retail, try to find out who the maker is and remember that Google is your friend.

More Links

Knowledge in this field expands annually. Here are a few further sources, but only a few:

Return to the top of this page.

  Sponsored link/s:

  Sponsored link/s:

If you find this site interesting or useful, please link to it on your site by cutting and pasting this HTML:
The <a href="http://growingtaste.com/"><b>Growing Taste</b></a> Vegetable-Gardening Site

--Site Directory--

Search this site, or the web
  Web growingtaste.com   

Since you're growing your own vegetables and fruits, shouldn't you be cooking them in the best way possible?
Visit The Induction Site to find out what that best way is!

If you like good-tasing food, perhaps you are interested in good-tasting wines as well?
Visit That Useful Wine Site for advice and recommendations for both novices and experts.

owl logo This site is one of The Owlcroft Company family of web sites. Please click on the link (or the owl) to see a menu of our other diverse user-friendly, helpful sites.       Pair Networks logo Like all our sites, this one is hosted at the highly regarded Pair Networks, whom we strongly recommend. We invite you to click on the Pair link (or their logo) for more information on getting your site or sites hosted on a first-class service.
All Owlcroft systems run on Ubuntu Linux and we heartily recommend it to everyone--click on the link for more information.

Click here to send us email.

So that you need not be a victim of the "Browser Wars," we have taken the trouble to assure that
this web page is 100% compliant with the World Wide Web Consortium's
XHTML Protocol v1.0 (Transitional).
You can click on the logo below to test this page!

Not every browser renders proper HTML correctly (Internet Explorer famously does not);
We strongly recommend the widely praised free, multi-platform Firefox browser.
Click on the image below to read all about it.

Get the Firefox browser!

(It's free!)

You loaded this page on Sunday, 16 December 2018, at 15:30 EST.;
it was last modified on Wednesday, 1 July 2015, at 19:29 EDT.

All content copyright ©1999 - 2018 by The Owlcroft Company